Current:Home > InvestAlex Murdaugh tries to prove jury tampering led to his murder conviction -CapitalCourse
Alex Murdaugh tries to prove jury tampering led to his murder conviction
View
Date:2025-04-16 06:39:09
COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — Alex Murdaugh is returning to a South Carolina courtroom, but this time the convicted killer, disbarred attorney and admitted thief won’t be fidgeting in the spotlight.
Instead, it’s the jurors who found him guilty of the shooting deaths of his wife and son who’ll be questioned by a judge. The unusual hearing Monday comes in response to allegations by Murdaugh’s attorneys that a clerk of court tampered with the jury that convicted him of murder last year.
Colleton County Clerk Becky Hill also is expected to be grilled by lawyers for Murdaugh, whose fall from his role as an attorney lording over his small county to a sentence of life without parole has been exhaustively covered by true crime shows, podcasts and bloggers.
Jury tampering is the basis for Murdaugh’s appeal, but Judge Jean Toal’s rulings after a pretrial hearing this month have set a difficult standard for his lawyers to prove.
Toal ruled the defense must prove that potential misconduct including alleged comments by Hill warning jurors not to trust Murdaugh when he testifies directly led jurors to change their minds to guilty.
The defense argued if they prove the jury was tampered with, it shouldn’t matter whether a juror openly said their verdict changed, because the influence can be subtle and still keep Murdaugh from getting a fair trial.
“According to the State, if Ms. Hill had the jury room decorated like a grade-school classroom with colorful signs saying ‘Murdaugh is guilty’ that would not violate Mr. Murdaugh’s right to a fair trial ... so long as jurors did not testify that they voted guilty because of the decor,” the defense wrote in a brief.
Toal also won’t let the defense call the trial judge Clifton Newman as a witness, nor prosecutors or other court workers who might testify that Hill seemed certain of Murdaugh’s guilt or tried to influence the case.
The judge also limited what can be asked of Hill. Toal told lawyers they can’t question the elected clerk about a criminal investigation announced by state agents into whether she used her office for financial gain, emailed prosecutors with suggestions on how to discredit a defense expert, conspired with her son who is charged with wiretapping county phones, or plagiarized part of her book on the case using a passage from a BBC reporter who accidentally emailed her instead of her boss with a similar address.
“I’m very, very reluctant to turn this hearing about juror contact into a wholesale exploration about every piece of conduct by the clerk,” Toal said.
Hill, in a sworn statement, has denied any jury tampering. .
Murdaugh, 55, is expected at the hearing in a prison jumpsuit. Even if he gets a new murder trial he won’t walk out free. He’s also serving 27 years after admitting he stole $12 million from his law firm and from settlements he gained for clients on wrongful death and serious injury lawsuits. Murdaugh promised not to appeal that sentence as part of his plea deal.
But Murdaugh has remained adamant that he did not kill his younger son Paul with a shotgun and his wife Maggie with a rifle since the moment he told deputies he found their bodies at their Colleton County home in 2021. He testified in his own defense.
The jurors, their anonymity protected, will be allowed to enter the Richland County Courthouse through a private entrance. The hearing will be televised, but their faces cannot be shown and they will only be identified by their juror numbers.
If this effort fails, Murdaugh hasn’t even started the regular appeals of his sentence, where his lawyers are expected to argue a number of reasons why his murder trial was unfair, including the judge allowing voluminous testimony of his financial crimes. They said this enabled prosecutors to smear Murdaugh with evidence not directly linked to the killings.
veryGood! (158)
Related
- FACT FOCUS: Inspector general’s Jan. 6 report misrepresented as proof of FBI setup
- Inter Miami vs. New York Red Bulls recap: Messi scores electric goal in 2-0 victory
- Environmental groups recruit people of color into overwhelmingly white conservation world
- Heineken sells its Russia operations for 1 euro
- US wholesale inflation accelerated in November in sign that some price pressures remain elevated
- Yogi Berra was a sports dad: Three lessons we can learn from his influence
- Winners and losers of Trey Lance trade: 49ers ship former third overall pick to Cowboys
- College football Week 0 winners and losers: Caleb Williams, USC offense still nasty
- Macy's says employee who allegedly hid $150 million in expenses had no major 'impact'
- Powell says Fed could raise interest rates further if economy, job market don't cool
Ranking
- What do we know about the mysterious drones reported flying over New Jersey?
- Why is Dolphins QB Tua Tagovailoa so hated? The reasons are pretty dumb.
- At least 7 shot in Boston, police say
- Prigozhin’s final months were overshadowed by questions about what the Kremlin had in store for him
- Will the 'Yellowstone' finale be the last episode? What we know about Season 6, spinoffs
- GM pauses production of most pickup trucks amid parts shortage
- Novak Djokovic's results at US Open have been different from other Grand Slams: Here's why
- Jacksonville killings refocus attention on the city’s racist past and the struggle to move on
Recommendation
What to know about Tuesday’s US House primaries to replace Matt Gaetz and Mike Waltz
Global inflation pressures could become harder to manage in coming years, research suggests
New Mexico Game Commission to consider increasing hunting limits for black bears in some areas
What to stream this week: Indiana Jones, ‘One Piece,’ ‘The Menu’ and tunes from NCT and Icona Pop
Israel lets Palestinians go back to northern Gaza for first time in over a year as cease
The dream marches on: Looking back on MLK's historic 1963 speech
Verstappen eyes ninth straight F1 win after another Dutch GP pole. Norris second fastest
The Highs, Lows and Drama in Britney Spears' Life Since Her Conservatorship Ended